Showing posts with label The Mote in God's Eye. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Mote in God's Eye. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 9, 2007

SF Online Interview with Hagio (Part IV-3)

Chojin Taikei or The Birdman Chronicle - by Osamu Tezuka(Continued)

Sakai:

You are quite a humanist.

Mizutama:

That's like a life-long spell that all people who grew up on Tezuka are cast into.

Hagio:

It is a bit different from humanism. It's okay if someone is purely a villain, but in "The Mote in God's Eye" there is a species called Warriors, as well as those aliens who breed them. I have to question the setup where such aliens who breed those Warriors exist. For example, even if fierce bears and lizards fight, it's in a different vein, but they're still members of a biological system, right? With these Warriors, that part is completely missing.

Sakai:

You mean, it's very mechanical.

Hagio:

That's right. Even if you enter into a battle, how do I say, I think there is a fateful encounter in it. So whether you are out to destroy your opponent or close the gate, if there is a conflict within a character, it is much more interesting to us as humans. It is too simplistic to leave out all these things just because they are villains.

Mizutama:

So you look for justification in a villain.

Hagio:

The reason why I was reminded of Tezuka was that, in his works, internal struggle is always present in the protagonist's actions.

Mizutama

"The Adventures of Rock" is all about that. "The Birdman Chronicles," too.

Hagio:

Right.

Mizutama:

So was "Zeroman."

Hagio:

Tezuka has empathy even when he depicts disfigured characters.

Sakai:

By the way, you have not done any SciFi lately…

Hagio:

Mmmm, that's right, not lately. Sorry. I'm involved in a long-term serialization. This will end in one year. I have been saying it for three years, but I would like to go back and try some more SciFi once that's done.

Mizutama:

Yay! I'll look forward to it. Oh, of course I enjoy reading the current serialization, too, but please also do SciFi, that's what I mean.

Sakai:

Ah, what a conclusion. (laugh) Thank you very much for today.

(End)

SF Online Interview with Hagio (Part IV-2)

Ender's Game - by Orson Scott Card(Continued)

Hagio:

Talking about strange space aliens, what was it, the one with the Earth occupied by several different kinds of space aliens. That humanoid one, what was it called…

Mizutama:

Sorry, it doesn't ring a bell.

Sakai:

Occupied?

Hagio:

There are plots and subplots, but you've got rock-shaped aliens, who make enormous efforts to move just one centimeter. In addition, Simak also features strange space aliens. But I actually don't like Simak's view of space aliens very much.

Sakai:

What don't you like?

Hagio:

Isn't it somewhat grotesque?

Sakai:

When it comes to space aliens you get two kinds. With one, the external shape may be human-like or not, but they think like humans. But there are people who depict aliens as something completely different from humans. Which kind do you like?

Hagio:

I like them both. But when Heinlein depicts a bad space alien, he tends to make it really grotesque, and I don't like it very much. There are cases where I would like to complain to the protagonist [author?] to think more about biology. When it comes to that, eh, that author who did "Ender's Game…"

Mizutama:

Isn't that Orson Scott Card?

Hagio:

I like his view of space aliens. So I am sorry, but I don't like the view of space aliens in "The Mote in God's Eye" by Niven and Pournelle, either. I don't know what to say, but once you create a character in life form, it's wrong not to have any sympathy toward it. The authors make them into massacre machines. Tezuka would never have done it that way, I think.

(Continues)